Ziert Alert! from Beijing

print Print version Comment Comment
email E-mail This Article to a Friend

Well, it's Friday, Aug. 8th, and the Games are really about to begin! After all the wait, previews and predictions, the actual show will begin. Of course, hours before the Opening Ceremonies, I am quite sure that it will be the biggest and best one yet — Oops, another prediction, but I feel very confident about this one.

Morgan Hamm speaks to the press in Beijing after announcing he was stepping down
I arrived in Beijing late Wednesday night so I missed the men's podium training. However, many Americans watched it live on the Internet. OK, the American men had a less-than-impressive showing from what I have heard, but remember this is just a dress rehearsal. Nevertheless, from what IG has learned, the men's program personnel pushed the big panic button, and irrationally created a situation which I know they will regret later. Sources have told IG that Morgan Hamm became the scapegoat for this shaky rehearsal. Mind you he is a very experienced gymnast and the only member of the team who has competed in an Olympics — plus he was instrumental in helping the U.S. to the team silver in Athens.

Apparently Morgan was strongly encouraged to get a cortisone injection to help with his ankle problem. That was on Wednesday. Then on Thursday morning, at the team practice in front of the entire delegation, he was told to do a complete floor routine or be removed from the lineup. It might have been nice for Morgan to know that the night before, and even more importantly, before he elected to have the injection. Thinking that all this wonderful advice on Wednesday was to help him be really ready for Saturday morning's competition, he obviously was not prepared to do the routine then and there. I'm still checking, but I do not think a federation can remove someone from their Olympic team in this situation. Seems there's something like athletes' rights guaranteed by the USOC. But then, of course, Morgan "resigned" his position and boarded a plane back to the U.S. It just seems that in a civilized world, things could be done in a classier way with more respect for the athletes. After all, isn't the USA most proud of its stand on civil liberties?

Although I had Paul Hamm in the line up and not Hagerty, the team that the U.S. men have ended up with is precisely the one that I had picked after the trials. I feel that Paul was essential to any medal hope, but I feel this team is the best one the U.S. can put on the floor at this time. They are a group of real fighters so I wish them well. I just hate all the unnecessary drama that USAG creates when it should be an easier and fairer way to deal with these wonderful young adults who have chosen to be gymnasts.

I was only able to watch the final rotations of the first session of women's podium training, but luckily that had the Chinese on bars and Romania on floor. The Chinese women look very well prepared and quite relaxed. I think they are fully aware that if they hit their routines they will be the Olympic team champions. He and Yang were truly incredible. They handle such high difficulty with such ease. It's a joy to watch this team, not only for their performances but their team spirit and camaraderie.

I watch the entire second session that included the Americans, Italians, Japanese and British. The Americans look ready; they were very solid in most all of their performances. Of special note is how ready Nastia Liukin seems. I have never seen her so confident and beautifully prepared. If she can just survive "assistant coach" Marta Karolyi for another few days, she will do very well. On the Marta note, was anyone else annoyed by the tone and witchiness in her voice during podium training? Could someone please mute her? I feel that everything about her is detrimental to this team that appears to be in a real fight for gold. Shawn seemed a little off her game — maybe just a bad day, but I hope that she can hold it together so the world can see both her exciting gymnastics and wonderful personality. My heart aches for Chellsie Memmel, who seemed so ready for this competition just a few weeks ago and now has to show her true grit again. Well, at least it looks like she can add Olympian to her resume. Sam Peszek, Bridget Sloan and Alicia Sacramone looked very good in this training. I only wish Marta had given this team the time to offer a higher level of difficulty which they are very capable of doing — just not everyday on hard surfaces in a remote gym outside of Houston, Texas. This American team appeared to be ready to put extreme pressure on the Chinese, who are trying to win their first ever Olympic team gold.

Poor Vanessa Ferrari. She is struggling so much that it's painful to watch. For example on floor, she faced her opening full-in, fell on her second pass of triple full and then faced pike double dismount. Her ankle is wrapped so I'm sure she is still having difficulties with injuries. It is hard to watch someone who dazzled the world just two years ago have to fight to live through this important competition.

The Japanese looked immensely improved especially on bars and beam. Although they appeared to struggle on floor and vault like the Chinese did years ago, they are performing beautiful gymnastics here.

Beth Tweddle looks so fit here. Although she is not doing beam or vault because of a rib injury, she looked very good on bars and floor. Although I missed her full routine on bars, we have been told that she has prepared a 7.9 A-Panel routine... WOW!

The Chinese host speaks with Olympic champions Nadia Comaneci and Donovan Bailey and actor Jet Li

I missed the last two session of podium training because I attended the "adidas Golden Night" party with IG's Nadia Comaneci and Bart Conner and their 2-year-old son, Dylan Conner. It was a wonderful celebration of adidas' commitment to Olympic sports. Remember it won the rights over Li Ning and Nike to outfit all the volunteers here. Although the entertainment was world class, the highlight of the evening however was Dylan doing his "moonwalk" on stage for all 500 guests. No wonder they say never work with kids or animals!

Let the competition begin!


IG Publisher Paul Ziert coached Bart Conner to two gold medals at the 1984 Olympic Games in Los Angeles, and was the assistant coach for the U.S. women's team in 1980. He was inducted into the USA Gymnastics Hall of Fame in 2006.

Rate this article
3.18

Comments (19 posted):

Penguin888 on Friday, August 08, 2008
Thanks for the report!
Do you have any notes on how the Japanese women did? I would love to hear anything you have about them.
Thanks again!
Anda on Friday, August 08, 2008
I am very curious to know how the Romanians did? Any good?
Ianthe on Friday, August 08, 2008
Your veiled comments towards Marta Karolyi are inappropriate. Her management of USAG is certainly open to criticism, but insulting her voice, of all things, was uncalled for. Question her management of the system, and leave the personal grudges out of it.
rachelmoran on Friday, August 08, 2008
lanthe you need to read closer. He wasn't insulting her voice but her TONE.

Personally I agree. Telling the girls how to warm up for beam? Telling them that this will be the time in the competition that they should pay attention?

I couldn't tell if they were Olympians or level 5s.
Matt Kisner on Friday, August 08, 2008
There is a great deal to be said for the Marta's leadership, as anyone who remembers 1997-2000, should recognize. If the US team were all training independently, in their own gyms scattered across the country they would not be nearly as prepared nor would they have been pushed to achieve the level of difficulty we have now. We must remember that the Chinese women achieved their level of difficulty essentially by being raised in such a training camp, living with their coaches and one another away from their families from a very young age. Compared to this, a dozen camps a year seems a very attractive American solution to the weaknesses of a decentralized system. I wonder if Ziert's comments aren't based on personal dislike. As a subscriber to IG for many years, I am seriously considering cancelling my subscription if there is not more of an opportunity for opposing editorial points of view to be expressed. I've listened to Ziert's long enough.
gizmogrl0707 on Friday, August 08, 2008
WOW! A 7.9 A score for Tweedle! I can't wait to see that!
TCO on Friday, August 08, 2008
Marta's tone was just fine. And the girl's workout was very well organized. This will help them be less nervous when they get on the floor and move event to event during the games. The men needed some Marta too. And yeah...drop the catty crap: everyone knows what "witchy" rhymes with...
Focacize on Friday, August 08, 2008
I agree with Ziert and Rachel M.
I was shocked to hear Marta giving instructions about chalking up for bars. Theses girls have all competed internationally with Marta before but all of the sudden they need instructions about competition?
Exactly Rachel, level 5 or elites? Marta seems nervous and to be giving unnecessary last minute instructions. Her behavior made me hope that the individual coaches were keeping a level head and maintaining their authority over her.
JennFyre on Friday, August 08, 2008
Paul we get it you don't like Marta. What is your solution? In the past 8 years the girls and coaches have become closer with one another then ever imaginable. Everyone works together. I saw Valerie spotting all of the girls on bars not just his daughter. This is a huge change from the power struggles in the just a few years ago. A successful team needs centralization in this day and age. Someone needs to make sure each coach is putting together successful routines and that the athletes are ready. I don't know if Marta is the only women who can do this but I don't think she has any bad intentions or is trying to make bad decisions. GEEEZZZ
tripleback on Friday, August 08, 2008
everyone knows what "witchy" rhymes with...

Kasperovichy!
Fat Girl on Friday, August 08, 2008
It's not the centralization that is the problem, it's the excessive having to prove yourself at every competition. Meaning, there was tremendous pressure to peak for Nationals and Trials just to make the Selection Camp, that, by the time the Olympics come by, they are at their most prone to being injured due to burn out, fatigue, and overtraining on hard surfaces every day without much rest in between training. I really wanted to see All-Around Chellsie. The Olympic Trials process is a joke. Look at what happened in Athens, the remaining six were really the only ones remaining who could be fit enough to hit routines without dying.
tdrz on Saturday, August 09, 2008
I agree Martha has become drunk with power and Paul Ziert is one of the few people in a position of power who will stand up to her. Unlike Kathy Kelly or her bumbling stooge Gary Warren who simply kiss her behind. They don't give a rip about these kids and just want to win at all costs. Bravo to you Paul Ziert for speaking your mind I support you 100 percent, we need more people like you. I am glad that you are back and speaking freely.
tdrz on Saturday, August 09, 2008
One has to wonder if at the age of 66 is Martha looking to win gold this year and then retire? Maybe that is why she is acting this way even more than usual.
KristyJ on Saturday, August 09, 2008
I just finished watching the womens' podium training, during which I kept a keen eye on Marta and the gymnasts' reactions to her. I have to say that I did not see the "witchiness" Mr. Ziert mentioned. What I did see included a great deal of "good jobs," "well dones," and "that's how it's done!" with a few scattered corrections (I counted two) and an effort to help the girls manage their time so that they can focus on their gymnastics. It seems a fitting job for the national coordinator to prompt the gymnasts to use their time effectively, and I don't think such promptings, even if delivered in a serious tone of voice, are that great of a distraction. After all, isn't organizing details part of a coordinator's job?
Though I was only able to observe what was shown during the online coverage, I still wonder if those who are critical of Marta see what they want to see and not what is actually happening.
sweetsteel on Saturday, August 09, 2008
I think the choice to make Marta the "assistant coach" was a very poor one. The girls are accommodating and polite with her but you can tell she brings a certain level of uneasiness. The Karolyi's have done great things for the sport, including centralizing training. It is just that it is time for both of them to step back. The old way worked then, but this is a new era of gymnastics. These girls are intrinsically motivated to achieve greatness as a team. They do not need the ridiculously lengthy and unhealthy trials. They should have been focusing on polishing their routines the last couple of months, not rather or not they were going to stay healthy long enough to make the team.

Chellsie is likely injured again because she eats fruit for breakfast, a few grams of protein for lunch and "maybe" some more fruit for dinner. I thinks she is a very brilliant and beautiful young girl with a lot to offer the sport, but she needs to take better care of her body. We have enough solid nutritional information in this day in age to know what foods best fuel athletes and eating like a bird is not going to do it.

If the Americans fall to the Chinese here it won't be for lack of talent or hard work but unnecessary over training, a distracting selection process and poor nutrition.
ickle on Sunday, August 10, 2008
A random question, but does anyone know what was with the backpacks the gymnasts were wearing? What happened to normal gym bags?
toepoint22 on Sunday, August 10, 2008
What happened to all of the Ziert alerts? He used to do them much more frequently at major events.
gym-fan on Thursday, August 14, 2008
The information you've written about Morgan Hamm is stunning and merits aggressive investigation. To allow this type of behavior by officials go unquestioned is to be a passive accomplice. If that's true, it's an absolute outrage. IG has a journalistic obligation to its readers to pursue this allegation relentlessly. There should be zero tolerance for this type of behavior.

You have an obligation to your readers to thoroughly investigate this matter.
gym-fan on Thursday, August 14, 2008
The information you've written about Morgan Hamm is stunning and merits aggressive investigation. To allow this type of behavior by officials go unquestioned is to be a passive accomplice. If that's true, it's an absolute outrage. IG has a journalistic obligation to its readers to pursue this allegation relentlessly. There should be zero tolerance for this type of behavior.

Post your comment comment

Olympic Medal Count

Country Total
11 2 5 18
2 6 2 10
2 2 5
1 1 2
2 2
2 2
1 1 2
1 1 2
1 1 2
2 2
2 2
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1