Broken Ankle Can't Sideline Memmel

print Print version Comment Comment
email E-mail This Article to a Friend
Memmel competes on bars in the Olympic team finals

U.S. gymnast Chellsie Memmel revealed Thursday that the bum ankle that limited her to one event at the Olympics wasn't just tweaked — it was broken.

But that couldn't stop the 20-year-old former world champion from contributing to the U.S. team's silver medal.

"I'm at the Olympics and I'm not going to pass this up," she told the press in Beijing. "It's a 'suck-it-up' moment."

Memmel broke her lower right tibia while tumbling Aug. 1, eight days before the Olympic team competition began. USA Gymnastics stayed mum about her condition, stating cryptically that it was "monitoring her condition."

Prior to the injury, Memmel likely would have competed all four events for the U.S. team in preliminaries. The ankle injury meant she chalked up for uneven bars only.

In Sunday's qualifying, Memmel missed a Tkatchev, losing a chance for the individual event final. She was on her game, however, in the 3-up-3-count team final on Tuesday. Punctuated by a stuck double front dismount, her routine brought 15.725, the fifth-highest score of the night for the Americans.

"Under the circumstances, amazing!" is how her father and coach, Andy Memmel, evaluated his daughter's performance in Beijing.

Up until Friday, the U.S. could have replaced her with one of three alternates training in Japan, a short flight away. The alternates included Jana Bieger, a triple silver medalist at the 2006 World Championships.

However, Andy Memmel told IG there was no question that Memmel would compete in Beijing if she could still do uneven bars.

Memmel's uneven bars set was a crucial part of the U.S. team's challenge to the host Chinese. The co-world champion on the event in 2003, Memmel is the only American besides Nastia Liukin to boast an A-Panel score of 7.0 or above.

It isn't the first time Memmel has proven her toughness. She suffered a broken foot in May 2004, but recovered quickly enough to be an alternate to the U.S. team to Athens, and won the all-around at the 2005 Worlds. At the team finals at the 2006 Worlds in Aarhus, she suffered a torn shoulder on uneven bars but finished the routine, and competed on balance beam and floor exercise.

Memmel will not need a cast, and the injury will not prevent her from taking part in the 30-city "Gymnastics Superstars" tour that begins Sept. 7.

"We X-rayed it today and it is healing well," Andy Memmel said Thursday.

Rate this article
3.90

Comments (10 posted):

rachelmoran on Thursday, August 14, 2008
I'm glad Memmel was able to compete but I hope her dad or USAG looks into her famous diet of fruit and chicken and if that caused all these injuries. Where is the calcium? Carbs for muscle repair?
marikis on Thursday, August 14, 2008
She is a GREAT girl! The nation can be proud of her.
ModelGymnast on Thursday, August 14, 2008
My mum said the same thing about her diet. Hopefully, she's taking calcium supplements and such to make up for what she doesn't consume in food...
alisonclements on Thursday, August 14, 2008
Urm - does anybody else think it is absolute madness that the USA felt it had to rely on a girl with a BROKEN LEG BONE to compete in the Olympics? There were 3 alternates and 3 other members of the team, leaving aside the other 305 million Americans in the country. "Suck it up" is a sadistic phrase anyhow, but in the context of a broken bone is lunacy!
JudgeJulie on Thursday, August 14, 2008
I hate to bring out the obvious, but wasn't it selfish for the Memmel's not to pull her in order to let a 4 event athlete compete? This might have changed the team line up.
Stephthemagicdragon on Thursday, August 14, 2008
It must have really hurt when she came off on the Tkachev cos she landed on the harder mats standing up. I'm surprised they let her compete with that sort of injury, I would have thought the risk of permanently damaging herself would outweigh the desire for medals, even if it is the Olympics. She is certainly very brave.

The number of injuries the US gymnasts are getting is really worrying though, Mattie Larson + Shayla Worley break their legs at training camp, Chellsie breaks her ankle in Beijing, Sam Peszek sprains her ankle. I think their coaches are probably pushing the too hard to get lots of big skills that they should take more time to learn.
doughnuthoes on Thursday, August 14, 2008
I feel bad that Chellsie didn't have the Olympics she dreamed of and deserves. Still, I am really glad for her that she won a silver medal.

I hope she knows that '08 will not be the only thing she is remembered for!
tdrz on Thursday, August 14, 2008
The decision to keep her on the team after the injury helped lead to the US silver. With Chellsie only able to do bars and being kept on the team the margin of error for the US was zero. The injury to Peszek made the margin of error insurmountable to defeat China becuase the US essentialy had two gymnasts (Memmel and Peszek) who could only compete 1 event.
sprinklefriend on Monday, August 18, 2008
don't get me wrong, i've been pulling for chellsie all the way - but looking back, it was a REALLY bad call not to replace her. we needed her and it hurt us overall to lose her. we could've put in someone like jana (not the greatest but consistent) who has the experience & can hold up under it... ANYONE who could've been counted on all-around. i was at olympic trials - meaning i saw a lot more than what was on tv - and we had the depth. i REALLY hate to say this (really) but we should've replaced her. unlike with samantha's injury, there was time, and we took a risk that may have been part of why we placed second.
Wisconsin Fan on Sunday, August 24, 2008
Hasn't this occurred previously with our women gymnasts? Didn't Bela have to carry someone off the mat? I'm sure she gets calcium and carbs as well as chicken and fruits.
Chellsie did a great job!!!

Post your comment comment

Olympic Medal Count

Country Total
11 2 5 18
2 6 2 10
2 2 5
1 1 2
2 2
2 2
1 1 2
1 1 2
1 1 2
2 2
2 2
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 1