Has Paul Hamm Really Retired?

• Paul Hamm's last-minute withdrawal from the U.S. Olympic team gave Raj Bhavsar reason to believe in the system that he felt had short-changed him in 2004, when he was an alternate in Athens. That's where Bhavsar, a noted ringman, sat in the stands and watched the U.S. concede .887 to Japan on rings. In the end, Japan defeated the U.S. for the gold by .888.
• Though it wasn't a complete surprise that Bhavsar was added to the U.S. team, I thought Alexander Artemev had a shot. The Americans are much weaker on pommel horse than on rings, but as Artemev proved (to his own detriment) during the trials process, horse is harder to hit than rings. From an age standpoint, Artemev, 22, has a better shot at 2012 than Bhavsar, 27.
• Chellsie Memmel's selection to the Olympic team is certainly one of the feel-good stories of 2008, considering her ill-timed injury four years ago. Her situation in 2004, when she broke a bone in her foot on balance beam, wasn't too different from that of fellow Wisconsin native Paul Hamm this year. Both just needed more time to heal.
• On Monday, July 28, Hamm told reporters he was finished with competitive gymnastics, but perhaps time will temper the frustration he is obviously feeling right now. It killed me to see him skip the last three world championships while at his gymnastics peak, but I understand that other factors played a part in that decision. Still, as tennis now thrives via the Roger Federer-Rafael Nadal rivalry, gymnastics could have benefitted from a few more Hamm-Yang Wei duels.
At 25, Hamm still has some good years left, and he's one of the most complete all-arounders ever. So I'm hopeful he'll reconsider and extend his comeback. Heck, he's 10 years younger than Jordan Jovtchev, who's about to compete in his fifth Olympics.
• 2008 U.S. champion David Sender says he's been going to the gym "a few times a week" since rolling an ankle prior to the Olympic trials. He has one more quarter left at Stanford, and is in the process of applying to veterinary schools. I asked him about the current situation with the U.S. men's team. "Unfortunately, with the team that they made, they kind of put all their eggs in one basket, assuming or hoping that Paul (Hamm) would be healthy and ready to go on all six events," he said. "Without him, there are a lot of holes to fill."
I wonder if Sender, who is only 22, will compete again, and mentioned to him that he had a national title to defend next summer. He chuckled with a hint of irony and said, "We'll see."
When asked if he had any interest in, say, the 2009 World Championships, Sender offered, "Right now I really have no reason to make a decision one way or another." Later in our conversation, he added, "I do still miss it. I definitely still have a passion for the sport. It's just a matter of whether or not I want to put up with it still, I guess."
Even though that sounds like a loaded statement, I'm taking it as a maybe. And if Sender feels as if the rug got pulled out from under him at the trials, I think the U.S. men's program should roll out the red carpet to keep such a talented gymnast around.
• The integrity of track and field has suffered tremendously because of its long history of steroid use, and now gymnastics is in the news because of questionable ages of certain Chinese gymnasts. The New York Times did some digging and found a few published birth dates for He Kexin and Jiang Yuyuan that suggest they are too young to compete in the Olympics this year. This is not new to gymnastics, but for some reason it doesn't seem to gain much traction. I suppose it's because there is no reliable testing for passports.
• I am interested to see how the Romanian women fare in Beijing, considering they are the defending Olympic champions. But 2004 was under the old reign of Octavian Belu and Mariana Bitang, both of whom will be in Beijing under new titles. Belu is the Minister of Sport for Romania, and Bitang is the Consiliere to Romanian President Traian Basescu.
With Belu and Bitang looking on from the VIP seats, Nicolae Forminte will coach his first Olympic team for Romania, which has won a team medal in every Olympics since 1976, including three golds (1984, 2000, 2004). Think he's feeling any pressure?
- U.S. Picks Men's Olympic Team
- Comaneci: No Question in Chinese Victory
- Ziert Alert: Alicia, It's Not Your Fault
- Chinese Women Claim First Olympic Team Title
- Pretty in Pink, Liukin Wins All-Around





Comments (5 posted):
Chellsie deserved her spot on the team. This whole year has been a great story for Chellsie and, you're right, it's a feel-good one. This will in all likelihood be her last Olympics, so I'm glad she made the team and I look foward to seeing her strut her stuff in Beijing!
Paul... well, I would love nothing more than to see him return. Honestly, I adore watching him perform. I thought that there might have been a chance of him returning for 2012 when he made the 2008 team. I mean, if anyone can go for their fourth Olympics (now an unfortunate third), it would be Paul Hamm! But I think that he's going to go back to school now, like he was planning. This is a huge blow to him. I fear that he really is retiring. I just hope that he sticks around the community whether he retires or not (and after he retires should he choose to go for 2012). He's a great sport and someone like I'd like to see in the future.
David Sender's story is probably the most heart breaking story of the entire 2008 Olympic year. He didn't even get a huge injury and it wasn't even from gymnastics! At least Paul had his chance to prove himself. Poor David never stood a chance. He sounds so defeated in his statements. If I were him, I'm honestly not sure I would return to gymnastics for anything other than a recreational sport. However, I hope he reconsiders. I'd like to see him defend his title or, even better, try to make it to 2012. We'll see.
In the end, there's no way to proof how old these Chinese gymnasts are. Any of them. Sigh.
Artemev also would have been my pick to come fill the spot of the decent scoring PH routine that is lost because Paul can't compete. He can score well even with falling. But I evaluated all three guys and it looked like they each had a one, two, and three ranking for the events I felt were crucial to fill now, which were PH, SR, and PB. So it was kind of even to me based on Nationals and Trials scoring and I think either of the guys could have helped the team well on one event. I am very happy that Raj is getting this opportunity, though, and I hope he can compete well and thoroughly enjoy the Olympic experience. I think he is the more reliable and experienced out of the three alternates, so it is good that he is picked.
Sender, I hope he continues. I sent him a card to let him know how bad I felt for him and to encouraged him to continue. I think he was getting better as well and may have been able to become a really dependable gymnast for the team, more so than the past.
I am also extremely happy that Chellsie has made the team. I think she is the toughest female gymnast competitor we have, and it is good to see that all her hard work has paid off and that she has recovered in time. She really is a crucial gymnast for this team.
Post your comment