Newsletter
Email:

Poll: World Records in Scoring
Should the FIG celebrate 'world record' scores, as it originally promoted?

Random thoughts on the gymnastics world

European Championships: Romania proved its superiority within European borders last week, but its winning total of 181.525 is still well shy of challenging for anything brighter than bronze at the Beijing Olympics. The U.S. won the 2007 World Championships with 184.400, with China second at 183.450.

Still, Romanian gymnasts should be highly motivated in August, since any Romanian Olympic champion will earn a bonus of 100,000 euros, plus a car. And if that’s not incentive enough, the women’s gymnastics team was recently proclaimed “our great hope for Olympic Games” by Traian Basescu, president of Romania.

Though a Romanian team victory in Beijing seems unlikely, we shouldn’t forget that this relatively small nation found a way to win the women’s team title at Athens 2004 over the U.S., which was world champion at the time.

United States: How deep is the U.S. women’s team right now? When the final six are chosen to compete in Beijing, the Olympic team could include four world champions who combined have won eight individual world titles: Nastia Liukin (3); Shawn Johnson (2); Chellsie Memmel (2); and Alicia Sacramone (1).

Olympic Wild Cards: The Olympic Creed states that “the most important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win but to take part,” which is a noble thought. And I agree. So when Nashwan Al-Hazari (Yemen) and Di Thi Ngan Thuong (Vietnam) received the final two berths to the Beijing Olympics, I understood that certain criteria factored into the selection process (geographical representation being one of them).

That said, I can only wonder how Greece’s Dimosthenis Tambakos received the men’s wild card to the 2004 Athens Olympics, since Greece already was represented by two-time high bar world champion Vlasios Maras.

When FIG Men’s Technical Committee President Adrian Stoica was asked in 2004 about a perceived home advantage for Tambakos, who won the Olympic gold on rings, he told IG, “Maybe the home advantage was set in the moment of the allocation of the wild cards!”

For the record, the women’s wild card in 2004 went to Bolivia’s Maria Jose de la Fuente, who placed 61st in Athens. That was special, because Bolivia isn’t exactly a hotbed for any sport other than soccer.

Gymnastics crowd at Utah
Is this seat taken? The University of Utah drew 15,447 spectators for its March 28 dual meet in Salt Lake City. It was the largest crowd in NCAA gymnastics history, and all the more impressive because it was not against a top team. The seats were overflowing (official seating capacity is 15,000 at the Huntsman Center) because of Senior Night, and the frenzied fans watched their beloved Utes defeat 29th-ranked BYU, 197.100-193.850.

Utah senior Ashley Postell, who has placed second all-around to Georgia’s Courtney Kupets at the NCAAs the last two years, is the top-ranked all-arounder for 2008. With Kupets out with a torn Achilles’ tendon, the title is Postell’s to win or lose. “I do think she’s the best all-around gymnast in college this year,” says Utes coach Greg Marsden of Postell, who is also ranked first on vault and beam. “But she has to have a great meet, because there are many good [gymnasts]. Anything can happen.”
Rate this article
5.00
print Print version Plain text Plain text
email E-mail to a friend

Comments (6 posted):

Elizabeth Booth on April 11, 2008
avatar
I agree. Gymnastics in Europe has definitely seen a downturn since the demise of the Eastern bloc regimes. I may be the only person in the world to think this, but hasn't the whole sport of women’s gymnastics taken a downturn also, since the 80s and early 90s? I get tired of watching sequences of 'skills' rather than complete routines. Perhaps I should limit my comments to beam and floor, as bars and vault seem less affected. It annoys me to see competence rewarded (no errors - no deductions) while brilliance (superior execution and style) apparently goes unnoticed. I dream of Ilienko’s floor routines, Mostepanova’s beam, daydream Boginskaya choreography as I catch an earful of appropriate music. This is in stark contrast to the living nightmares of certain gymnasts qualifying for beam and floor finals with little more than acrobatics skills. Could the fact that my hair is turning grey be connected to repeated exposure to an incomprehensible judging system? Or are my expectations of just a bit too high? Do we need a group hug?

How Chellsie Memmel could be considered to be the equal of Nastia Liukin is beyond me, and while Pavolva's floor routine may not be the most accurate or difficult, it does at least fulfill the idea of gymnastics as an expression, something I find sadly missing in 98% of the remaining exercises performed. I don't see this extra dimension reflected in Pavlova’s marks; I just see the elements added up and deductions made for the mistakes. It’s a bit flat, isn’t it? The judges calculate the marks objectively rather than making those subjective distinctions that surely separate gymnastics from many other sports.

Russia isn't the force that it once was, although I'm glad to see a renewed energy and spirit for the sport and the juniors as ever provided technical and style highlights to remind me of the heyday of my youth (I'm now so old I can remember the names of the 1985 Soviet team, but not the Russian team of 2004).

The geographical focus of the sport has changed; the whole epistemology of judging; the artistic standard of gymnastics has suffered dreadfully. Are these things connected? Does a change in geographical and cultural focus necessarily force a deterioration in aesthetic values?

Elizabeth
Ana Cossani on April 12, 2008
avatar
I really agree with Elizabeth. I also remembered 1996 Olympics when Lilya Podkopayeva's floor routine was the exact mix of gimnastics and art. Her expression, her movements, her smile... Mo Huilan and Dominique Moceanu too... they smile all the time, it was part of the artistic elements.

Why do gymnasts don't smile any more?
Elaine Michaels on April 13, 2008
avatar
Ana, have you seen Sandra Izbasa's FX at the recent Europeans? She had the most beautiful smile on her face for most of the second half of her routine. It absolutely warmed my heart to see it. Her choreography is so-so, but she has great music and presentation to match. She's maturing into a very beautiful gymnast to watch.

Sadly, I, too, have to agree with Elizabeth on the general state of women's gymnastics. Whatever happened to having, you know, dance elements on beam? Or even an actual choreography? Today's beam routines are a travesty. There is no attempt at beautiful connections between the skills, and the skills themselves aren't pretty, either. Side somis, anyone? Ugh. I'm so sick of seeing those. Side and front aerials landed on two feet? Ugly, very ugly. Front aerials and front somersaults ending in an arabesque? Rather unsightly when performed by gymnasts who aren't sufficiently flexible or stable to pull them off. Nope, I really can't see much beauty in today's beam routines. And don't get me started on today's floor exercises. Five tumbling series in one routine is two too many, as far as I'm concerned. Double-twisting leaps do not make up for a total lack of elegance and presentation. And most importantly, moving one arm while standing in a corner for six seconds catching one's breath does NOT constitute dance. Aaargh. Will we ever see a proper floor exercise again?

I really hope the new code will improve things somewhat, but I'm sceptical.
Katelin O'Grady on April 14, 2008
avatar
Good point Ana, gymnasts don't seem to smile anymore. i know when i compete i forget sometimes, but the best feeling in the world is sticking that skill, or completing that routine. but i love seeing expression and enjoyment and love for the sport when a gymnast is preforming, and i call it preforming not competing cause thats what there doing, they preform there floor routine or beam routine.... bring back smiles i sayyy..... haha.. bye all...
Ana Cossani on April 14, 2008
avatar
You're right Elaine. I wrote this comment and then I was sourprise when I saw Izbasa's FX at the recent Europeans. I love it. Her smile remembered the olds routines, and the music, sounds just perfect (nowadays some gymnasts choose musics with no rithm!)

I hope she's doing her best at Beijing, I'll love to see Romanian's gymnasts on the top.

(Sorry for my English, it's not good at all)
Kevin Silvestre on April 14, 2008
avatar
I certainly hope that Ashley Postell wins the NCAA all-around title this year. She has been so consistent this season, averaging a 39.705 in the all-around! However, she does face some stiff competition from the likes of Tasha Schwikert (UCLA), Tiffany Tolnay (UGA), Katie Heenan (UGA), Tabitha Yim (Stanford) and Ashleigh Clare-Kearney (LSU). With UGA having the home-field advantage this year at nationals, a UGA Gym Dog might just be able to steal the AA crown from her.

Post your comment comment

Please enter the code you see in the image: